Stepping into a leadership role is a major achievement, whether you’re a seasoned professional or newly promoted. But with the title comes the challenge of leading diverse teams—including those who may be older, more experienced, or even perceived as “smarter.” While these situations might seem daunting, they’re also incredible opportunities to grow as a leader and strengthen your team. Each scenario requires careful navigation rooted in trust, relationship-building, and an unwavering commitment to growth.
Let’s look at common leadership challenges and strategies to navigate them effectively.
Challenge #1: Leading People Older Than You
When managing someone older, it’s natural to wonder if they’ll take you seriously, especially if there’s a significant age gap. As a younger leader, you might worry they’ll see your age as lacking experience or knowledge. This perception can lead to insecurities, but it’s essential to acknowledge your capabilities. Remember that you were promoted for a reason. Checking your doubts and showing confidence in your role can go a long way in establishing your authority without arrogance.
Strategies
· Acknowledge Experience: Begin by recognizing their expertise and asking for their insights. This shows respect and opens the door for collaboration. Engaging in one-on-one conversations where you discuss team goals and solicit their input helps get everyone on the same page.
· Be Confident, Yet Appropriately Vulnerable: Confidence and vulnerability are critical. Don’t shy away from admitting when you don’t know something. By being honest, you create space for mutual respect and demonstrate that you value their experience.
· Practice Generosity: Support their growth and celebrate their achievements. Leaders who generously share credit and give meaningful feedback cultivate trust and admiration. Recognize that older team members may have different needs or life responsibilities—do what you can to support them.
Challenge #2: Leading People with More Expertise
Sometimes, leaders are brought in for their people skills or strategic vision rather than technical expertise. This can be challenging when team members know more about the technical details than you do. The key is to use your role to empower their abilities rather than trying to compete with them.
Strategies
· Leverage Their Knowledge: Seek their input on technical aspects and clarify that you value their expertise. This builds credibility and enables you to lead effectively without needing to be the subject matter expert.
· Promote Open Communication: Encourage regular discussions to allow for knowledge-sharing. Facilitate an environment where questions and ideas flow freely and demonstrate that you’re there to support their work.
· Stay Committed to Learning: Continuously develop your knowledge in areas relevant to your team. Participate in workshops, stay updated on industry trends, and seek feedback. This shows a dedication to growth that helps bridge any perceived gaps in expertise.
Challenge #3 Leading People Who Are Smarter Than You
Intelligence takes many forms. Some of your team members might excel in analytics and strategic thinking or possess highly specialized knowledge. In such cases, your role isn’t about competing intellectually but facilitating a culture where everyone’s strengths are maximized.
Strategies
· Be an Advocate for Team Success: Instead of focusing on individual achievements, champion the team’s collective intelligence. Emphasize shared goals and celebrate each person’s unique contributions.
· Encourage Collaboration: Inspire your team to share ideas and problem-solve together. When intelligent individuals work as a unit, you create a resilient team better equipped to handle challenges.
· Showcase Adaptability: Adaptability and resilience are essential leadership traits that often resonate with highly intelligent individuals. Share stories of overcoming obstacles, demonstrate flexibility in the face of new information, and actively engage in problem-solving. This conveys your strength as a leader committed to personal and team growth.
Ultimately, leadership isn’t about age, expertise, or who’s “smartest” in the room. I t’s about building trust, leveraging each person’s strengths, and guiding the team toward shared success. As a leader, your responsibility is to foster an environment where every team member feels seen, heard, and empowered.
Quote: "The greatest leader is not necessarily the one who does the greatest things. [They] are the ones that get the people to do the greatest things." – Ronald Reagan
Question: How do you handle leading people older or more experienced than you? Comment and share below; we’d love to hear from you!
The next blog in this series will focus on another leadership challenge of being the only woman in the room.
As a leadership development and executive coach, I work with leaders to sharpen their leadership skills and navigate tricky situations, contact me to explore this topic further.
How Do You Lead Those Senior Than You?